Pizza restaurants

Two Brother's Pizza

4.1 202 reviews 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM 4317 Forrest Ave, Dover, DE 19904, United States

Discover this place

At Two Brother's Pizza, located at 4317 Forrest Ave in Dover, DE, the locality buzzes with praise for its delicious offerings and stellar service. Customers rave about the party pizza, notable for its thinner slices that allow for easy enjoyment without wastefulness. Laura Franze, a loyal customer, highlights the generous toppings and reasonable prices that keep her returning, expressing her preference for this family-run business over larger chains.

Others echo these sentiments, with Sarah McCrea emphasizing the outstanding customer service and quick preparation times. The pizzas arrive hot and delicious, ensuring satisfaction with each order. Kaitlyn Arnett, a first-time visitor, appreciated the care in her special requests, particularly praising the light sauce on her pepperoni pizza and the mouthwatering cheesy fries with bacon.

Overall, Two Brother's Pizza stands out not only for its delectable food—packed with generous portions of meat and cheese—but also for its warm, friendly service. Loretta Way notes the positive interactions with staff even during busy times, proving that this pizza joint is committed to customer happiness, one slice at a time. Whether you're a longtime local or a newcomer, this pizzeria promises a delightful dining experience worth the drive.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Two Brother's Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Two Brother's Pizza

4.1

202 reviews

100%

22%

15%

23%

Review highlights

Based on 202 reviews

Two Brother's Pizza in Dover, DE, is frequently recognized for its generous toppings, fresh ingredients, and well-prepared menu offerings that consistently meet customer expectations. Reviewers often highlight the quality and flavor balance, with special mention of items like the party pizza and specialty sides, which are praised for both taste and portion size. The establishment’s family-run atmosphere and attentive customer service are commonly noted, contributing to a positive and welcoming experience even during busy periods. While some feedback points to minor issues such as outdated contact information, the overall consensus underscores prompt order preparation and food temperature maintenance. Patrons also appreciate the value for money and prefer supporting this local pizzeria over larger chains, indicating strong community loyalty and satisfaction with both dine-in and carryout options.

Laura Franze

Jun 26, 2025

We do Two Brothers for carryout and love it. The party pizza is great with thinner slices so it is easier to eat and not waste. Toppings are generous for the reasonable price. We way prefer supporting this family shop over the others. We arre not in delivery area but do not mind the drive.

Sarah McCrea

Jun 03, 2025

I don’t understand all of the negative reviews. I absolutely love their food! My husband and I have ordered pizza, cheesesteak, broccoli bites and fries so far from here. The customer service is outstanding, the food is always hot and delicious, also always ready super fast! I will continue to order from here. Don’t listen to the negativity

Kaitlyn Arnett

May 16, 2025

first time here as we just moved closer to the area and everything was amazing, from Karen (i believe) taking my order over the phone, to the best pizza! we will definitely be ordering from here in the future and plan to try more menu items! food was hot and fresh! i had a small pepperoni pizza and ordered light sauce (sensitive to red sauce) and it was perfect! also got cheesey fries with bacon and they were so delish!

Kaitlyn Rodriguez

Apr 09, 2025

Great food and great service. Closed for renovations for a little while but they’re opened back up! Phone number online isn’t correct. See picture for new phone number.

Loretta Way

Apr 03, 2025

Our pizza had a generous amount of meat and cheese, it was really good. Definitely will order from here again! Staff was very friendly even though it was a busy evening. I only waited a few minutes when I arrived at the beginning of the estimated time to pick up.

Kelly

Mar 29, 2025

The owner is very nice and helpful. I will recommend this pizza place to everyone.

Tonirae Stevens

Mar 23, 2025

My Husband And I Had Our First Meal From Two Brothers Today We Had A Philly Cheese And Cheese Sub It Was Delicious

Justin Willey

Mar 17, 2025

The owner bought our things at the dollar general, than offered to pay for an extra large pizza for our family and refused to let us pay for the 2 liter he also gave us. Very grateful for the experience and recommend supporting these guys definitely